
Matthew Smith recommends John Krautner’s amazing new album CINNAMON LAKE
John Krautner’s new album, released on vinyl a few months ago, is already out of print, so until a second pressing arrives, you’ll have to listen to it online or get someone to make you a cassette or something. After a couple decades making great music with the Go and Conspiracy of Owls, as well as an impressive bubblegum project that resulted in his first solo LP, John has made a new record that is now considered an instant classic by everyone who has managed to get hold of a copy.
John had been playing these songs at solo acoustic gigs with a nylon-stringed guitar, so I heard some of the songs before they were recorded. When John sings these songs, he sounds like Flo AND Eddie, or Ed Sanders if Ed could sing like Harry Nilsson. Sometimes he reminds me of the soul-singer-with-an-acoustic-guitar Terry Callier, or even Rodriguez. I’ve played gigs with both Rodriguez and John Krautner and I can definitely say they have certain things in common. Rodriguez liked to play nylon-stringed acoustic guitars, wrote enigmatic songs with a midwestern streetwise perspective, and had one of the best voices you could find in any genre of music. John has all these qualities, and they are all evident in the grooves of his album CINNAMON LAKE.
CINNAMON LAKE is not “indie rock”. It’s a bunch of songs, delivered the way people used to deliver them in days gone by when there was a higher standard expected when one delivered a bunch of songs. The whole thing is enveloped in a seemingly Brazilian-sounding psychedelic swamp-folk haze, which is the result of John allowing producer Jimbo Easter the total creative freedom necessary to take the songs to a higher level of inspired actualization. Jimbo’s experience as a visual artist and musician is well documented, and producing a record for another artist was something new for him. I suspect that one of the reasons this record sounds so different from all the other records being made these days is that Jimbo approached the music like a visual art project, or a sculpture, and he apparently had the various guest musicians lay down overdubs that could then be used to build an unexpected sonic landscape to surround John’s solo acoustic performances. By unexpected, I mean that John probably had no idea what the record was going to sound like when he first laid down the solo tracks. This approach is probably similar to the production methods that resulted in classic albums like Cold Fact by Rodriguez and The Nightmare of J.B. Stanislas by Nick Garrie, two “solo acoustic” albums with unusual arrangements and atmospheres.
I could address each individual song, but there’s really no point in that if you haven’t heard it yet. There are songs about bats, darkness, cigarettes, lightning, dreams, and all kinds of things that are not obvious or predictable, exactly what you would want to hear when someone picks up an acoustic guitar and starts singing. There’s nothing predictable about this record. It’s not like other singer-songwriter records. It’s filled with sounds and imagery that build up a strange atmosphere. It’s like Leonard Cohen performing on the set of The Creature from the Black Lagoon, or Lee Hazlewood in a forest at 3 AM playing in front of a campfire surrounded by the cast of an American International biker flick. It’s weird like that, but also reassuringly familiar in the sense that it’s good to know someone can still make records the way they used to.
CINNAMON LAKE is available as a digital download on bandcamp.
Editor’s Note: Matthew Smith is the singer/songwriter for Outrageous Cherry and The Matthew Smith Group. Smith produced two classic albums by the Go that feature John Krautner, WHATCHA DOIN’ in 1999, and the just-released 2001 recording FREE ELECTRICITY, as well as contributing a mind-bending virtuosic synthesizer solo to their song “Kevin and Georgie.”

John Krautner and Matthew Smith performing at the Detroit Institute of Arts 8/14/26, photo by Cary Loren.
